Progressive solidification is usually considered an effective strategy to reduce the hot tearing susceptibility of a cast component. In this study, special constrained plate castings with progressive changes in cross-section were designed, which enabled progressive solidification. The hot tearing behavior of a newly developed NZ30K Mg alloy (Mg-3.0Nd-0.2Zn-Zr, wt.%) was studied under progressive solidification using various mold temperature distributions and constraint lengths. Of these, a homogeneous mold temperature distribution is found to be the best option to avoid hot tearing, followed by a local low mold temperature distribution (with a chiller), then a gradient mold temperature distribution. Unexpectedly, compared with the homogeneous mold temperature distribution, adding a chiller does not provide any further reduction in the hot tearing susceptibility of the NZ30K Mg alloy. A high mold temperature and a short constraint length increase the hot tearing resistance of cast Mg alloys. Progressive solidification is not a sufficient and necessary condition to avoid the formation of hot tearing. The two key factors that determine the occurrence of hot tearing under progressive solidification are the maximum cooling rate and the constraint length. Decreasing these values can reduce the incidence of hot tearing.